Free guide · Demand letters, step by step

Got an ADA website demand letter? What to do in the first 7 days

A demand letter about your website's accessibility is alarming — and it is not a court judgment. This page walks through the first week in order: what to read, what to preserve, what not to do, how to find out what is actually wrong with your site, and how to respond with a real plan.

An honest starting point. This guide is practical information from a website-checking service, not legal advice and not a substitute for an attorney. We cannot tell you what your letter is worth, whether to settle, or what a court would do — nobody honest can, without reading it. What we can do is lay out the order of operations that keeps your options open: the businesses that handle these letters best are the ones that neither ignore them nor panic-pay them in the first 24 hours.

Two things are true at once. First, most demand letters are sent in volume by a small number of firms, and the first amount named is an opening position. Second, the underlying issue is usually real: most small-business websites genuinely do have barriers — missing labels, keyboard traps, weak contrast — that lock out customers who use screen readers or keyboards. The plan below deals with both truths: protect yourself legally, and actually fix the site.

The first 7 days, in order

Day 0–1

1. Preserve everything before you change anything

Save the letter and the envelope it came in (or the full email with headers), and note the date you received it. Take dated screenshots or a screen recording of the pages the letter names, and save a copy of your site as it is today. Fixes come next — but you want a record of the starting point, because “what did the site look like when the letter arrived” is a question your attorney will ask.

Day 1

2. Do not reply in your own words

Do not call or email the sender to explain, apologise, argue or promise a timeline. Anything you write can be quoted back, and a well-meant “we will fix everything by Friday” becomes a commitment you may not be able to keep. A short holding reply, if any, is your attorney's job. The same goes for your web developer: no blame emails, no public posts about the letter.

Day 1–2

3. Work out what you are actually holding

Read the letter for five things: who sent it (firm and named plaintiff), which law it cites, the specific barriers it lists, the deadline it proposes, and what it wants — fixes, money, or both. Check whether it is a letter or a filed court complaint (a complaint carries a case number and a court). The two need different speeds: a complaint has formal court deadlines.

Day 2–3

4. Get an attorney who knows ADA website cases

Bring the letter, your preserved screenshots and your site address. Ask three questions: Is this firm/plaintiff known for filing if ignored? What does a settlement and release need to cover so the same claim cannot return? What remediation timeline is realistic to offer? Many business attorneys will review a first letter in a short paid consultation — far cheaper than learning the answers inside a lawsuit.

Day 2–4

5. Get the facts about your own site

Do not guess which of the letter's claims are true — measure. Run a scan of your homepage and key flows to list the machine-provable barriers (missing alt text, unlabelled controls, contrast failures, keyboard blockers) with the WCAG rule behind each. That dated list becomes the backbone of your remediation plan and shows good-faith effort from a specific date. Start free with our instant homepage check, and use the 12-point checklist for the barriers a scan cannot judge.

Day 3–7

6. Fix the real barriers, blockers first

Work the list by how completely each barrier blocks a customer: keyboard traps and unlabelled checkout or booking forms first, then labels, alt text, link names and contrast. Log every fix with its date and what changed. If a fix needs a developer, a severity-ranked report with plain-English instructions turns “make it accessible” into a priced, schedulable task.

Day 7 and after

7. Respond through counsel — and keep it fixed

Your attorney responds with the settlement position and your remediation plan: what is already fixed (with dates), what is scheduled, and how the site will be re-checked. Then make the fix stick: re-check after every redesign, theme change or new booking/checkout tool, and keep a dated record. Sites drift back into barriers quietly; a monthly re-scan is what catches that before a second letter does.

What not to do

Avoid

Do not ignore it and hope it goes away

Silence is the response most likely to turn a letter into a filed lawsuit. You do not have to accept the letter's claims to answer it — but answer it, through counsel, on the record.

Avoid

Do not pay the first number in the first week

The opening demand is not a fine set by a court. Paying quickly, without a written settlement and release reviewed by your attorney, can leave you exposed to a repeat claim about the same site.

Avoid

Do not install an overlay widget as the whole fix

An overlay does not repair the code underneath: unlabelled buttons stay unlabelled, keyboard traps stay traps. Letters in this area routinely say an overlay alone is not compliance, and accessibility professionals have criticised overlays for years. Spend the same money on real fixes.

Avoid

Do not delete the site or the evidence

Taking the whole site down stops your sales, not the claim — and changing pages before you have documented their current state removes the baseline your attorney and your developer both need. Preserve first, fix second.

The plan on one page

Print this page or copy this summary into your notes:

  1. Save the letter, the envelope and the date it arrived
  2. Screenshot the named pages before changing anything
  3. Do not reply, apologise or promise dates in your own words
  4. Read for: sender, law cited, barriers listed, deadline, what they want
  5. Check whether it is a letter or a filed complaint (case number)
  6. Have an ADA-experienced attorney review it
  7. Scan the site and list the real barriers, with dates
  8. Fix blockers first; log every fix and its date
  9. Respond through counsel with settlement position + remediation plan
  10. Re-check after every site change so there is no second letter

What this typically involves paying for

Three separate buckets — keep them separate in your head and in your records. Legal advice: reviewing the letter, negotiating and drafting a settlement with a proper release. Remediation: the actual fixes to your site, priced by your developer against a concrete barrier list. Settlement: only if your attorney advises it, and only against a signed release. Anyone who quotes you one flat number for all three, sight unseen, is selling, not advising. Our part is deliberately small and fixed-price: the dated Full Report that lists your provable barriers is $15 one-time, so the “what is actually wrong” question never has to be a guess or a big invoice.

Get the facts about your site first

The Full Report scans your site against WCAG 2.2 AA and returns a dated PDF: every barrier found, ranked by severity, each with a plain-English fix — the list your attorney and developer will both ask for. $15 one-time. The Watch Plan ($18/month) re-checks monthly so fixed barriers do not creep back.

Get my report — $15

Free instant homepage check · The 12-point compliance checklist

Reports are a first-line check and documentation of good-faith effort — not a certification of ADA or WCAG compliance, and not legal advice. Full refund if your report fails to generate; 30-day refund policy.

Frequently asked questions

Is an ADA demand letter the same as being sued?

No. A demand letter is a letter — usually from a law firm — claiming your website has accessibility barriers and asking you to fix them and often to pay a settlement amount. It is not a court filing and not a judgment. A filed complaint is different: it comes with a court case number and formal deadlines to respond. Read your letter carefully to see which one you are holding, and if a complaint was actually filed, treat the court's deadlines as real and urgent.

Should I just pay what the letter asks for?

Not before getting advice. The amount in a first letter is an opening demand, not a court-ordered figure, and paying without a proper settlement agreement may not protect you from a second claim. An attorney who handles ADA website matters can tell you what is typical, what a release should cover, and whether fixing the site first changes the negotiation. This page is practical information, not legal advice.

What if I ignore the letter?

Ignoring it is the riskiest option. Many demand letters are followed by a filed lawsuit if the business does not respond, and a lawsuit is slower and more expensive to deal with than a letter. You do not have to agree with everything the letter says — but a timely, documented response through counsel is almost always better than silence.

Should I take my website down?

Usually not as a first move. Taking the site offline stops sales and bookings, and it does not erase the claim about how the site was before. Some businesses temporarily limit a broken feature while it is fixed, but the standard path is: document the current state, fix the real barriers, and respond with a remediation plan. Ask your attorney before making the site disappear.

Does fixing my website make the demand go away?

Fixing the barriers is necessary but usually not sufficient on its own: the sender will normally still want a written settlement and a commitment that the site stays accessible. What fixing does do is strengthen your position — you can show dated findings, dated fixes and a real remediation timeline instead of promises. Keep records of every fix and its date.

Will an accessibility overlay or widget solve this?

No. An overlay adds a layer of scripts on top of your pages; it does not repair the underlying code — missing labels, keyboard traps and unlabelled controls stay in the page. Overlays are widely criticised by accessibility professionals, and plaintiffs' letters routinely state that an overlay alone is not compliance. Fix the actual barriers in the code or site builder, and use tools that find them.

How long do I have to respond?

A demand letter usually proposes its own deadline — often a few weeks — but that date is the sender's ask, not a court order. A filed complaint, by contrast, carries a formal response deadline set by the court. Either way, start in the first days: preserve the letter, get advice, and get the facts about your site while there is still time to act calmly.

Written by ADA Site Check, Portland, Oregon. Questions: contact@getadasitecheck.com. This guide is practical information, not legal advice, and not a certification of compliance with the ADA, WCAG or Section 508.